The idea of removing a member state from the Schengen Area has re-entered European political debate after thousands of migrants arrived in Ceuta, a Spanish enclave on the Moroccan coast. Several EU governments responded by calling for Spain to be suspended from the bloc's passport-free travel zone. For expats living in Germany — many of whom rely on Schengen freedom of movement to travel, visit family, or maintain multi-country professional lives — this debate is worth understanding clearly. The short answer from legal experts is: formal expulsion from Schengen is essentially impossible under current EU treaties. But that does not mean borders cannot come back in other ways.
The Schengen Area is a zone of 29 European countries (27 EU members plus Norway, Iceland, Switzerland, and Liechtenstein) that have abolished passport controls at their mutual borders. It is one of the most tangible benefits of European integration, enabling around 1.7 billion cross-border trips per year.
Schengen membership is governed primarily by the Schengen Borders Code, an EU regulation. Critically, there is no provision in the Schengen Borders Code — or in EU treaty law more broadly — that allows a member state to be formally expelled from the zone. Membership is tied to EU membership and the fulfillment of Schengen standards; removing a country would require changes to EU primary law, an enormously complex political and legal undertaking requiring unanimous agreement.
While expulsion is off the table legally, the Schengen Borders Code does allow member states to temporarily reintroduce border controls at internal borders under specific conditions:
Germany itself has exercised this right. Border controls at Germany's frontiers with Austria, Switzerland, Poland, the Czech Republic, and others have been reintroduced periodically in recent years, citing migration pressures and security concerns. As of 2024–2025, Germany had extended stationary controls at several land borders, affecting travelers entering from those countries.
The specific calls to "kick Spain out of Schengen" were largely political rhetoric rather than formal legal proposals. The arrival of large numbers of migrants in Ceuta — a Spanish territory on African soil — triggered anger in some EU capitals about external border management. Under EU rules, Spain as a Schengen member is responsible for controlling its external borders, including Ceuta.
The legal mechanism that could theoretically be used is Article 29 of the Schengen Borders Code, which allows other member states to reintroduce controls at borders with a country deemed to be failing in external border management. However, this is a far cry from "expulsion" — it means other countries could treat the Spanish border more like an external border temporarily, not that Spain leaves the zone.
For most expats in Germany on non-EU visas, Schengen travel is already governed by the conditions of your Aufenthaltstitel. If you hold a valid German residence permit, you can generally travel within Schengen for up to 90 days in any 180-day period without a separate Schengen visa. That baseline does not change because of political disputes between member states.
However, if border controls are reintroduced — as Germany has done at certain entry points — you may be asked to show your passport and documents at what would normally be an open border. Having your residence permit and passport on you during European travel remains essential practical advice.
Not directly, and not immediately. Your travel rights within Schengen are determined by your residence permit and the standard 90/180-day rule. Political calls to "remove" Spain from Schengen have no legal standing under current EU law and are unlikely to be acted upon formally.
Always carry your valid passport and your German Aufenthaltstitel when traveling in Europe. Even with open Schengen borders, you are legally required to carry identity documents in Germany at all times. At any reintroduced control point, border officers can ask to see these documents.
The debate about removing Spain from Schengen is a reminder that Europe's open borders are a political achievement, not a permanent guarantee — but the legal reality is that formal expulsion is not possible under current treaties. What is possible is a gradual return of border checks at specific crossings, which Germany and others have already been doing. For expats, the practical takeaway is simple: always travel with your documents, stay informed about active border controls via your country's travel authority or Germany's Bundespolizei website, and remember that your Schengen travel rights are tied to your residence permit status.
Source: The Local
Want news like this in your inbox?
The most relevant news for expats in Germany, no noise.
The AfD could make history in Saxony-Anhalt's state election. Here's what that means for migrants and people with a migration background living in Germany.
The AfD is using provocative live streamers to amplify its political message in Germany. Here's what this media strategy means for the political climate expats live in.
Unions, churches and sports clubs join forces to offer practical help to victims of right-wing extremist attacks and threats in Germany — including support for volunteers.
