Germany has taken a significant and controversial step in its deportation policy: for the first time, a person was deported to Afghanistan who had not been convicted of any criminal offence. Until now, returns to Afghanistan had been limited to individuals with serious criminal records. More flights are expected in the coming weeks and months. The move requires negotiated arrangements with the Taliban, who currently control Afghanistan — a fact that has drawn sharp criticism from human rights groups and opposition politicians. For the estimated tens of thousands of Afghan nationals living in Germany — many with temporary protection status or ongoing asylum proceedings — this development raises urgent questions about their legal security and future in the country.
For several years after the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan in August 2021, Germany suspended most deportations to the country, citing the dangerous and unpredictable security situation. Returns were only carried out in exceptional cases involving individuals convicted of serious crimes.
This latest deportation marks a clear departure from that position. German authorities confirmed that the deported individual had not been convicted of a criminal offence, meaning the criteria for removal have been broadened. The German government has signalled that this will not be an isolated case: further flights are being planned and are expected to take place with increasing regularity.
The policy shift comes amid a broader political debate in Germany about migration and border management, with pressure from several parties to take a harder line on returns to countries previously considered too dangerous.
Organising deportation flights to Afghanistan necessarily involves some form of coordination with the Taliban authorities, who control the country's airspace, airports, and borders. This is the central ethical and political flashpoint of the policy.
Critics — including human rights organisations such as Pro Asyl and Amnesty International — argue that any arrangement with the Taliban legitimises the regime and potentially endangers deportees, who may face persecution, imprisonment, or worse upon return. They point out that Afghanistan remains one of the most dangerous countries in the world, particularly for women, ethnic minorities, and anyone perceived as having cooperated with Western institutions.
The German government has not publicly detailed the nature of any agreements made with Taliban officials to facilitate the flights.
If you are an Afghan national currently living in Germany, this policy change is important to understand, even if your situation feels stable right now.
Temporary protection and tolerated status (Duldung): Those living in Germany under a Duldung (tolerated stay) — a temporary suspension of deportation — are potentially the most directly affected. A Duldung does not grant permanent residence rights, and its suspension can now more plausibly lead to actual removal.
Ongoing asylum cases: If your asylum application is still being processed by BAMF, the outcome of your case remains the decisive factor. However, the political environment around Afghan cases has tightened, and rejection rates may be affected over time by broader policy signals.
Recognised refugees and those with Aufenthaltstitel: If you hold a recognised refugee status or a valid residence permit, you are not subject to immediate deportation. However, it is always advisable to keep your documents up to date and seek legal advice if your situation changes.
Vulnerable groups: Women, LGBTQ+ individuals, journalists, interpreters, and others who have worked with Western organisations have long been recognised as facing particular dangers in Afghanistan. Legal counsel is strongly recommended for anyone in these categories.
Based on the most recent case, yes. While previous practice limited deportations to those convicted of serious offences, this case shows that German authorities are now willing to deport individuals without a criminal record. The legal basis for deportation in Germany rests on the status of a person's residence permit and asylum decision, not solely on criminal history.
First, do not ignore any official letters or notices from the Ausländerbehörde or BAMF. Contact a qualified immigration lawyer or a recognised refugee advice centre (Flüchtlingsberatungsstelle) as soon as possible. Organisations such as Pro Asyl, the Diakonie, and the Caritas operate advice centres across Germany. If you believe you face serious danger upon return — for example, due to your gender, ethnicity, religion, or past activities — this must be formally documented in your case.
No. If you hold a valid Aufenthaltstitel (residence permit), you are not in an immediate deportation process. Deportation proceedings apply to those whose asylum applications have been finally rejected and who are living under a Duldung or have no valid legal status in Germany.
Germany's first deportation of a non-convicted Afghan national signals a meaningful shift in how the country approaches returns to Afghanistan. The situation is evolving, and more flights are expected. If you or someone you know is Afghan and living in Germany with uncertain residence status, the most important step right now is to seek professional legal advice — ideally from a lawyer specialising in asylum and immigration law or from an accredited refugee support organisation.
Stay informed, keep your documents accessible, and do not wait for a formal notice before seeking help.
Source: Tagesschau
Want news like this in your inbox?
The most relevant news for expats in Germany, no noise.
The AfD could make history in Saxony-Anhalt's state election. Here's what that means for migrants and people with a migration background living in Germany.
The AfD is using provocative live streamers to amplify its political message in Germany. Here's what this media strategy means for the political climate expats live in.
Unions, churches and sports clubs join forces to offer practical help to victims of right-wing extremist attacks and threats in Germany — including support for volunteers.
